Thursday, May 31, 2007

Turnitin.com and Plagiarism

lately i've been thinking about plagiarism. i've had students, both in class and in the writing center, express deep anxiety about it, especially the "unintentional" version. i'm required to make a statement about it in my syllabus. the student handbook outlines disciplinary measures about it. but i wonder: is plagiarism really deserving of so much attention? or is it a kind of academic hysteria, a manufactured monster?

case in point: the debate around turnitin.com, which you can begin learning more about here.

plagiarism seems to me to be intimately tied to issues of copyright/copyfight, intellectual property, web 2.0, and the questions around exchange, retrieval, use and appropriation of content that define our current moment. as students, how would you feel if your work was submitted to turnitin? is plagiarism really the issue? as a teacher, i kind of think that you're not doing your job if you give writing assignments that are susecptible to plagiarism in the first place.

2 comments:

murphdizzle said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
murphdizzle said...

I have been thinking about what you wrote about turnitin.com, how the teacher is not really doing his or her job if there is a possibility of plagarism in a given assignment. It is definitely interesting to get a teacher's perspective on it. I don't completely agree though. Often times in history cases, not so much when analyzing primary sources, but when looking at secondary sources for background information, it is easy to plagarize instead of distilling information and putting it into your own words. Plagarism is also very apparent in written philosophy assignments. For example, whose words and ideas are you using? Are you using your words or Kant's? Just bored at work, interesting post.